Utah Supreme Court Upholds Constitutionality of Products Liability Statute

The Utah Supreme Court issued Egbert v. Nissan (“Egbert II”) in which it has expressly held:

1) The rebuttable presumption of non-defectiveness in product liability cases is constitutional and has been effective in Utah for more than 20 years; and

2) Restatement (Third) Torts section 16(b-d) regarding enhanced injury claims is rejected.  An “enhanced injury occurs when an injury caused by some other event is increased or enhanced due to a defective product.”  The Court found an inherent conflict between the restatement and Utah’s long-standing abolishment of joint and several liability and adoption of apportionment of fault.